image
Lucas Quintao
Banner for an article that talk about OSINT and CLOSINT analysis
Tutorials

OSINT & CLOSINT: Key Steps for Effective Threat Intelligence

In today’s cybersecurity landscape, gathering accurate and timely intelligence is critical for protecting both individuals and organizations. Two primary methodologies often used in this process are OSINT (Open Source Intelligence) and CLOSINT (Closed Source Intelligence). While OSINT focuses on freely accessible public data, CLOSINT dives into restricted, subscription-based, or underground sources for more specialized insight. Together, they form a powerful combination that can significantly bolster your security posture.

Below is a comprehensive guide divided into clear sections, detailing how and why you should integrate OSINT and CLOSINT into your threat intelligence strategy.

1. Introduction to OSINT and CLOSINT

1.1 What is OSINT?

Open Source Intelligence (OSINT) refers to data collection from publicly accessible sources. These can include:

  • Search engines (e.g., Google, Bing)
  • Social media platforms (e.g., Facebook, Twitter, LinkedIn)
  • Official public records and business registries
  • News articles, blogs, and discussion forums

OSINT is a cost-effective starting point that leverages the abundance of free data available on the internet. Because of its accessibility, OSINT is often the first step in any intelligence-gathering initiative.

 

1.2 What is CLOSINT?

Closed Source Intelligence (CLOSINT) involves the use of specialized sources and environments that are not freely accessible to the public. These can include:

  • Paid intelligence platforms
  • Private databases and government records
  • Deep Web and Dark Web marketplaces, forums, and other hidden services

CLOSINT is typically conducted by advanced cybersecurity teams, law enforcement, or specialized firms with the tools and expertise to navigate these closed ecosystems. Because it can unveil harder-to-find data—ranging from threat actor TTPs (Tactics, Techniques, and Procedures) to stolen credentials—CLOSINT significantly enhances situational awareness.

2. The Importance of Integrating OSINT and CLOSINT

  • Holistic Threat Picture: Relying solely on public data (OSINT) might leave blind spots. CLOSINT fills these gaps by uncovering information hidden behind paywalls or within illicit, underground communities.
  • Timely Incident Response: With both OSINT and CLOSINT, security teams can react quicker to emerging threats, data breaches, or active campaigns.
  • Proactive Defense: Advanced knowledge of threat actor tactics and compromised credentials enables security teams to proactively patch vulnerabilities and strengthen defenses.

3. Key Checks for Effective Threat Intelligence

Below are essential checks that combine both OSINT and CLOSINT to offer a comprehensive view of potential risks and threats.

3.1 Identities & Organizational Data

  1. Validate Personal or Corporate Information

    • OSINT Tools & Methods: Search for names, tax codes, or financial details (like IBANs) across official government registries, open databases, and business directories.
    • CLOSINT Sources: Cross-reference findings with subscription-based corporate intelligence databases or leaked data dumps found on the Dark Web. This can help verify the accuracy and legitimacy of the information.

  2. Investigate Social Media and Professional Networks

    • OSINT Tools & Methods: Platforms like LinkedIn, Indeed, or GitHub can be used to check employment history, skill sets, and endorsements. Consistent information across profiles can validate authenticity.
    • CLOSINT Sources: In some Dark Web forums, criminals might offer or request personal details. Monitoring these channels helps you spot attempts at identity theft or corporate espionage.

  3. Check for Data Breaches and Suspicious Mentions

    • OSINT Tools & Methods: Utilize free resources such as Have I Been Pwned to quickly see if email addresses or domains have been compromised.
    • CLOSINT Sources: Scrutinize underground forums and marketplaces where breached data is often traded or sold, providing early warning signs of potential targeted attacks.

3.2 Contact Details & Communication

  • Confirm Phone Number or Email Ownership and Reputation

    • OSINT Tools & Methods: Services like TrueCaller or reverse email lookups can validate if a contact number or address is legitimate. Email reputation tools (e.g., MXToolBox) help determine if a domain or server is flagged for spamming.
    • CLOSINT Sources: Threat intelligence platforms can provide detailed reports on phishing campaigns or spam operations linked to specific email addresses or phone numbers.

  • Check Known Breach Databases

    • OSINT Tools & Methods: Public leak checkers and media reports highlight major breaches, but often only provide basic details.
    • CLOSINT Sources: More advanced breach data or newly compromised credentials might only be available on private repositories or Dark Web markets.

  • Explore Clandestine Spaces for References

    • OSINT Tools & Methods: Traditional search engines won’t index hidden content, but certain aggregator sites and specialized browser extensions can give partial visibility into the deeper layers of the internet.
    • CLOSINT Sources: Accessing the Deep/Dark Web through Tor or specialized VPNs can uncover direct mentions of personal or corporate communication details, often indicating a risk of targeted phishing or impersonation.

3. Key Checks for Effective Threat Intelligence

3.3 Web and Domain Analysis

  1. Verify Domain and IP Reputation

    • OSINT Tools & Methods: Platforms like VirusTotal, Shodan, and AlienVault OTX provide initial intelligence on domain/IP activity.
    • CLOSINT Sources: Paid or restricted threat intelligence platforms might have deeper historical data on malicious campaigns tied to specific domains or IP ranges.

  2. Review Historical Site Data

    • OSINT Tools & Methods: Utilize Wayback Machine or other web archiving services to see how a website has evolved over time. Sudden changes or suspicious updates can hint at malicious activity or site compromises.
    • CLOSINT Sources: Internal or partner-based logs may reveal infiltration attempts, defacements, or other targeted attacks that aren’t publicly documented.

  3. Investigate Links to Malicious Activity

    • OSINT Tools & Methods: Basic scanning tools and publicly available reports can point out if a domain is hosting malware, phishing pages, or suspicious downloads.
    • CLOSINT Sources: Underground chatter might reveal a domain’s prior use in botnets, advanced persistent threat (APT) campaigns, or other coordinated attacks.

3.4 Threat Actors & Underground Forums

  1. Monitor Online Chatter and Dark Web Discussions

    • OSINT Tools & Methods: Follow open hacker forums, social media posts, and specialized news outlets that regularly report on emerging threat actors.
    • CLOSINT Sources: Dive deeper into private or invite-only channels, such as hacking communities or encrypted messaging platforms, to glean insider information about upcoming attacks or new exploits.

  2. Cross-Reference Threat Feeds

    • OSINT Tools & Methods: Use public threat feeds like RansomFeed or curated Twitter handles that track threat group activity.
    • CLOSINT Sources: Subscription-based platforms offer detailed TTP (Tactics, Techniques, and Procedures) reports, providing crucial insights into how threat actors operate and plan attacks.

  3. Identify Linkages and Patterns

    • OSINT Tools & Methods: Correlate data points found publicly to establish connections between known threat actors and their campaigns.
    • CLOSINT Sources: Access data sets with malicious Indicators of Compromise (IOCs) or real-time threat actor communications to confirm patterns of activity and attribution.

4. Best Practices for Combining OSINT and CLOSINT

  1. Use a Multi-Layered Approach

    • Rely on various OSINT and CLOSINT tools to cross-verify data.
    • Apply correlation techniques to see how information from open sources matches with insider or closed sources.

  2. Automate Where Possible

    • Employ scripts and automation tools (e.g., Python libraries, SIEM integrations) for continuous monitoring of both OSINT and CLOSINT feeds.
    • Automate alerts for any anomalies or new mentions of your organization, domain, or key personnel.

  3. Maintain Ethical and Legal Compliance

    • Abide by privacy and data protection regulations (e.g., GDPR) and ensure that you do not engage in unauthorized intrusions.
    • Obtain the right clearances or permissions if you are accessing restricted areas for intelligence collection.

  4. Document Your Findings

    • Keep detailed logs of every intelligence source, method, and finding for auditing and possible legal proceedings.
    • Build an internal knowledge base to streamline investigations for future incidents.

5. Conclusion

By combining OSINT and CLOSINT, organizations and cybersecurity professionals gain a 360-degree view of potential threats. OSINT provides a broad, cost-effective foundation for data collection, while CLOSINT dives into specialized platforms and hidden online realms for deeper, more actionable insights. This dual-pronged approach bolsters your ability to detect, analyze, and mitigate potential security risks before they escalate.

In an era where data breaches and sophisticated cyber threats continue to rise, leveraging both OSINT and CLOSINT checks—including verifying identities, analyzing communications, investigating domains, and monitoring underground forums—is crucial. By following these key steps and best practices, you can proactively strengthen your cybersecurity posture and stay one step ahead of evolving threats.